Sale and agreement to sell, are two terms that are often used interchangeably, but they denote very different meanings. While a sale refers to the immediate transfer of property ownership, an Agreement to Sell involves a commitment to transfer ownership at a future date. In a sale, the buyer becomes the legal owner instantly, whereas an agreement to sell outlines conditions for the transfer, which occurs later or upon fulfillment of specified terms.
What is a sale?
In real estate transactions, a sale signifies the immediate and final transfer of ownership from seller to buyer. This transfer occurs upon the fulfillment of specific conditions, typically payment of the agreed-upon price and execution of the sale deed.
Upon completing the sale, the buyer assumes full ownership of the property, along with any associated risks and rewards.
Two main features of a sale are :
- Immediate ownership transfer upon payment and deed execution.
- Buyer assumes property ownership, risks, and rewards.
For Example, you purchase a ready-to-occupy apartment. Upon completing the payment and registering the sale deed, you become the legal owner, bearing any future risks or enjoying potential benefits like appreciation in value.
What is the nature of the Contract?
A sale is considered an executed contract, meaning all obligations have been fulfilled upon the transfer of ownership. The sale deed serves as the final document, signifying a complete and binding transaction.
What is an Agreement to Sell?
An agreement to sell, while similar in its intention to transfer ownership, differs significantly in its timing. Here, the transfer of ownership does not occur immediately but at a future date or upon the fulfillment of certain conditions. This agreement serves as a binding promise to transfer ownership, but the actual transfer remains contingent.
Two main features of an agreement to sell are:
- Agreement to sell delays ownership transfer until future conditions are met.
- Binding promise, with ownership transfer contingent on fulfillment.
For examples, you enter into an agreement to purchase an under-construction apartment, with completion and possession scheduled for two years later. Until then, ownership remains with the builder, and you haven't assumed any risks or rewards associated with the property.
Until the transfer of ownership takes place under an agreement to sell, the associated risk and reward remain with the seller. This means the seller bears the risk of any damage or loss to the property before the agreed-upon date or condition is met.
Find Your New Office. Fast!
Present in Mumbai, Navi Mumbai, and Thane.
*Please enter a valid name.
*Please enter a valid phone number.
*Please enter a valid company name.
*Please enter a valid carpet area.
What is the Nature of the Contract ?
An agreement to sell is considered an conditional contract, meaning both parties have obligations to fulfill before the deal is complete, the sale is finalized and ownership is transferred. The seller must fulfill the agreed-upon conditions, and the buyer must make the payment. The transaction remains incomplete until all conditions are met.
Difference Between Sale and Agreement to Sell
| Parameter | Sale | Agreement to Sell |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Transfer of ownership from seller to buyer in exchange for money | Transfer of ownership from seller to buyer at a later date |
| Nature | Immediate transfer of ownership | Promise to transfer ownership later after fulfilling certain conditions |
| Type of Contract | Simple contract | Conditional contract |
| Title | The title is transferred to the buyer with the execution | The title is not transferred until the agreed-upon future date |
| Transfer of Risk | Risk is typically transferred to the buyer immediately after payment | The risk of loss or damage remains with the seller until the agreement conditions are fulfilled |
| Right to Sell | Once the contract is executed, the seller has no right to sell the property | The seller can sell the property to another party if the buyer is unable to meet the agreement conditions |
| Tax | Liable for sale tax | May vary as per the jurisdiction, and the terms of the agreement |
| Consequences of damage to the goods | Buyers bear the cost of damages after the transfer of ownership | Seller may be responsible for any loss or damages, since the ownership is not transferred yet |
| Relation | It involves a direct transfer of ownership from seller/s to buyer/s | An agreement to sell consists of a promise to transfer ownership later |
| Subsequent Responsibility | Seller’s obligations are usually completed upon transfer of ownership | Loss is borne by the seller |
| Statutory Law | Includes various statutes, including: Indian Contract Act, 1872 Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Sale of Goods Act, 1930 | Mainly a subject of the Sale of Goods Act, 1930 |
Why is knowing the difference important?
Given the potential legal and financial implications, ensuring clear and unambiguous contractual terms is crucial for both sale and agreement to sell transactions.
Key elements to cover while drawing up a contract are as follows:
Specific definition of the transaction: Clearly state whether the agreement is a sale or an agreement to sell.
Detailed description of the property: Include accurate details like location, size, and title status.
Conditions for ownership transfer: If it's an agreement to sell, clearly outline the conditions for ownership transfer.
Payment schedule and terms: Specify the payment amount, schedule, and any penalties for late payments.
Risk allocation: Clearly define who bears the risk of any damage or loss before ownership transfer.
Dispute resolution mechanism: Establish a process for resolving any potential disputes.
Seeking legal advice from a qualified professional is highly recommended to ensure the contract accurately reflects your agreement and protects your interests.
Case Studies: Real-World Scenarios
Scenario 1: Ready-to-Occupy Apartment
You decide to purchase a ready-to-occupy apartment from a developer. You sign a sale deed and make the full payment. Upon registration of the deed, you become the legal owner of the apartment, assuming all risks and rewards associated with it.
If there are any renovations or non compliance of amenities, the buyer has to bear the expenses This is an example of a sale, with immediate ownership transfer.
Scenario 2: Under-Construction Apartment
You enter into an agreement to purchase an under-construction apartment from a builder. The agreement specifies ownership transfer upon completion of construction and obtaining occupancy certificate. Until then, the builder retains ownership of the property.
In case of conflicts such as delayed possession, title disputes, defects, legal non-compliance, the builder or the seller bears the responsibility of taking care of said conflicts before transferring ownership to the buyer. This is an example of an agreement to sell, with ownership transfer depending on future events.
Conclusion
In a city like Mumbai, where about 50% of all legal transactions conducted are illegal, understanding the fundamental differences between a sale and an agreement to sell allows you to navigate the real estate market with clarity. By carefully considering the legal and financial implications, opting for clear and well-drafted contracts, and seeking professional advice when needed, you can ensure a secure and successful transaction.
Transparency is hard to come by in a highly regulated market like real estate and peace of mind starts with educating yourself in ways to protect your high value investment. Remember, knowledge is power, especially when it comes to safeguarding your investments in the dynamic world of real estate.
